| 2nd Period Play-by-Play |
| | Start of 2nd period [15:00]. |
| [15:00] | Faceoff Eddie McDonald vs Chad Calderwood won by ONUM, [15:00] Ground ball pickup by ONUM Ethan Hojnacki. |
| [14:28] | Clear attempt by ONUM failed. |
| [14:28] | Turnover by ONUM Joe Keeley. |
| [14:26] | Ground ball pickup by OTT Lincoln Troxell. |
| [13:53] | Turnover by OTT Nick Clay (caused by Joe Keeley). |
| [13:48] | Clear attempt by ONUM good. |
| [12:49] | Shot by ONUM Will Edkins HIT POST. |
| [12:28] | GOAL by ONUM Caleb Bennett, Assist by Will Edkins, goal number 14 for season. |
| Ohio Northern men 2, Otterbein 0 |
| [12:28] | Faceoff Eddie McDonald vs Chad Calderwood won by OTT, [12:28] Ground ball pickup by OTT Eddie McDonald. |
| [12:12] | Turnover by OTT Eddie McDonald (caused by Chad Calderwood). |
| [12:09] | Ground ball pickup by ONUM Chad Calderwood. |
| [12:05] | Clear attempt by ONUM good. |
| [11:29] | GOAL by ONUM Caleb Bennett, goal number 15 for season. |
| Ohio Northern men 3, Otterbein 0 |
| [11:29] | Faceoff Eddie McDonald vs Chad Calderwood won by OTT, [11:29] Ground ball pickup by OTT Eddie McDonald. |
| [11:21] | Shot by OTT Aidan Moore BLOCKED. |
| [11:17] | Ground ball pickup by OTT Anthony Flores. |
| [10:54] | Shot by OTT Max Graham, SAVE Cole Zaferakis. |
| [10:51] | Penalty on ONUM Andrew Reimer (UNNECESSARY ROUGHNESS/1:00) Extra-man opportunity. |
| [10:40] | Shot by OTT Aidan Moore WIDE RIGHT. |
| [10:25] | GOAL by OTT Nick Clay (MAN-UP), Assist by Aidan Moore, goal number 20 for season. |
| Ohio Northern men 3, Otterbein 1 |
| [10:25] | Faceoff Eddie McDonald vs Chad Calderwood won by OTT, [10:25] Ground ball pickup by OTT Eddie McDonald. |
| [09:40] | Turnover by OTT Cole Werbrich. |
| [09:34] | Clear attempt by ONUM good. |
| [09:02] | GOAL by ONUM Willy Hanson, Assist by Caleb Bennett, goal number 8 for season. |
| Ohio Northern men 4, Otterbein 1 |
| [09:02] | Faceoff Eddie McDonald vs T.J Smith won by OTT, [09:02] Ground ball pickup by OTT Nick Wile. |
| [08:46] | Shot by OTT Nick Wile WIDE RIGHT. |
| [08:40] | Penalty on ONUM Ethan Hojnacki (HOLDING/0:30) Extra-man opportunity. |
| [08:25] | Shot by OTT Nathan Lewis WIDE LEFT. |
| [08:17] | Shot by OTT Carson Rainone BLOCKED. |
| [07:36] | Shot by OTT Max Graham WIDE RIGHT. |
| [07:22] | Shot by OTT Max Graham WIDE LEFT. |
| [07:19] | Turnover by OTT. |
| [07:08] | Clear attempt by ONUM good. |
| [07:04] | Timeout by ONUM. |
| [06:00] | Ground ball pickup by ONUM Riley O'Neal. |
| [05:48] | GOAL by ONUM Sebastian Michaud, goal number 26 for season. |
| Ohio Northern men 5, Otterbein 1 |
| [05:48] | Faceoff Eddie McDonald vs T.J Smith won by OTT, [05:48] Ground ball pickup by OTT Nick Wile. |
| [05:21] | Ground ball pickup by OTT Max Graham. |
| [04:41] | Shot by OTT Ty Forney, SAVE Cole Zaferakis. |
| [04:21] | Shot by OTT Carson Rainone WIDE LEFT. |
| [04:06] | Turnover by OTT Aidan Moore. |
| [03:57] | Clear attempt by ONUM good. |
| [02:46] | Ground ball pickup by ONUM Will Edkins. |
| [02:45] | Turnover by ONUM. |
| [02:34] | Clear attempt by OTT good. |
| [02:19] | Timeout by OTT. |
| [01:59] | Shot by OTT Nathan Lewis, SAVE Cole Zaferakis. |
| [01:57] | Ground ball pickup by ONUM Nate Mitchell. |
| [01:43] | Clear attempt by ONUM good. |
| [01:41] | Turnover by ONUM Nate Mitchell (caused by Nick Wile). |
| [01:35] | Ground ball pickup by OTT Nick Wile. |
| [00:26] | Turnover by OTT Carson Rainone (caused by Joe Keeley). |
| [00:24] | Ground ball pickup by ONUM Joe Keeley. |
| [00:15] | Clear attempt by ONUM good. |
| [00:08] | Timeout by ONUM. |
| [00:04] | Turnover by ONUM Andrew Caliri (caused by Lincoln Troxell). |
| [00:03] | Ground ball pickup by OTT Lincoln Troxell. |
| [00:00] | End-of-period. |