| 1st Period Play-by-Play |
| [15:00] | Luke Farthing at goalie for OTT. |
| [15:00] | Cole Zaferakis at goalie for ONUM. |
| [15:00] | Faceoff Eddie McDonald vs Chad Calderwood won by OTT, [15:00] Ground ball pickup by OTT Lincoln Troxell. |
| [14:27] | Clear attempt by OTT good. |
| [14:00] | Shot by OTT Nick Wile HIGH. |
| [13:27] | Shot by OTT Nick Wile HIGH. |
| [13:27] | Turnover by OTT. |
| [13:05] | Clear attempt by ONUM good. |
| [12:40] | Turnover by ONUM Andrew Caliri (caused by Jackson Jerdonek). |
| [12:25] | Clear attempt by OTT good. |
| [12:16] | Turnover by OTT Cayden Rohe (caused by Jack Wasik). |
| [12:12] | Ground ball pickup by ONUM Joe Keeley. |
| [11:50] | Shot by ONUM Ryan McClure BLOCKED. |
| [11:36] | Turnover by ONUM Nathan Flynn. |
| [11:34] | Ground ball pickup by OTT Adam Clay. |
| [11:22] | Clear attempt by OTT good. |
| [10:52] | Shot by OTT Ty Forney, SAVE Cole Zaferakis. |
| [10:49] | Ground ball pickup by ONUM Nate Mitchell. |
| [10:38] | Clear attempt by ONUM good. |
| [10:14] | Turnover by ONUM John Lynn (caused by Adam Clay). |
| [10:11] | Ground ball pickup by OTT Miguel Need. |
| [10:07] | Clear attempt by OTT failed. |
| [10:07] | Turnover by OTT Miguel Need (caused by Sebastian Michaud). |
| [09:26] | Turnover by ONUM Alex Reimer (caused by Lincoln Troxell). |
| [09:24] | Ground ball pickup by OTT Lincoln Troxell. |
| [09:17] | Clear attempt by OTT failed. |
| [09:17] | Turnover by OTT Anthony Flores. |
| [08:31] | Shot by ONUM Ian Roy, SAVE Luke Farthing. |
| [08:22] | Ground ball pickup by OTT Adam Clay. |
| [08:12] | Ground ball pickup by OTT Anthony Flores. |
| [08:04] | Clear attempt by OTT failed. |
| [08:04] | Turnover by OTT Alex Menendez. |
| [07:20] | Turnover by ONUM Sebastian Michaud. |
| [07:18] | Ground ball pickup by OTT Adam Clay. |
| [07:11] | Clear attempt by OTT failed. |
| [07:10] | Turnover by OTT Luke Farthing. |
| [07:08] | Ground ball pickup by ONUM Riley O'Neal. |
| [07:00] | Turnover by ONUM Riley O'Neal (caused by Shep Marty). |
| [06:57] | Ground ball pickup by OTT Cole Werbrich. |
| [06:46] | Clear attempt by OTT good. |
| [06:30] | Ground ball pickup by OTT Nick Clay. |
| [06:27] | Timeout by OTT. |
| [06:00] | Shot by OTT Nathan Lewis, SAVE Cole Zaferakis. |
| [05:52] | Clear attempt by ONUM good. |
| [05:26] | Ground ball pickup by ONUM Ryan McClure. |
| [04:49] | Turnover by ONUM Ryan McClure (caused by Shep Marty). |
| [04:46] | Ground ball pickup by OTT Shep Marty. |
| [04:31] | Clear attempt by OTT good. |
| [04:27] | Turnover by OTT Alex Menendez (caused by John Copes IV). |
| [03:40] | Turnover by ONUM Riley O'Neal (caused by Adam Clay). |
| [03:38] | Ground ball pickup by OTT Luke Farthing. |
| [03:35] | Clear attempt by OTT good. |
| [03:29] | Turnover by OTT Cayden Rohe. |
| [03:23] | Clear attempt by ONUM good. |
| [03:00] | Shot by ONUM Ryan McClure BLOCKED. |
| [02:38] | Turnover by ONUM Sebastian Michaud (caused by Adam Clay). |
| [02:36] | Ground ball pickup by OTT Adam Clay. |
| [02:20] | Clear attempt by OTT good. |
| [01:50] | Turnover by OTT Nathan Lewis. |
| [01:48] | Clear attempt by ONUM good. |
| [01:01] | Shot by ONUM Aidan Dempsey, SAVE Luke Farthing. |
| [00:58] | Ground ball pickup by OTT Lincoln Troxell. |
| [00:49] | Clear attempt by OTT failed. |
| [00:49] | Turnover by OTT Nick Wile. |
| [00:40] | GOAL by ONUM Sebastian Michaud (FIRST GOAL), Assist by Aidan Dempsey, goal number 25 for season. |
| Ohio Northern men 1, Otterbein 0 |
| [00:40] | Faceoff Eddie McDonald vs Chad Calderwood won by OTT, [00:40] Ground ball pickup by OTT Adam Clay. |
| [00:21] | Clear attempt by OTT good. |
| [00:03] | Shot by OTT Ty Forney, SAVE Cole Zaferakis. |
| [00:00] | End-of-period. |